Employee vs contractor
Get classification right
By the wpdailylive editorial team · Part of HR for small business, the complete guide
Key takeaways
- Control is the test: If you control how, when and where they work, they’re usually an employee.
- Reality beats paperwork: A contract label doesn’t override how the work actually happens.
- Common mistake: An estimated 10–30% of employers misclassify some workers.
- UK rules: IR35 off-payroll rules apply to contractors working through companies.
- Contract for contractors: Even genuine contractors need a written agreement.
Whether someone is an employee or an independent contractor decides who pays their taxes, whether they get overtime, holiday pay and benefits, and what happens if things go wrong. The label you use and the contract you sign don’t decide it: the reality of the working relationship does.
| FACTOR | EMPLOYEE | INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR |
|---|---|---|
| Control | You set hours, methods and location | They decide how, when and where to do the work |
| Tools and equipment | You provide them | They provide their own |
| Exclusivity | Works mainly or only for you | Has other clients and markets their services |
| Pay | Salary or hourly wage through payroll | Invoices per project or deliverable |
| Financial risk | None; paid regardless of results | Can make a profit or a loss |
| Integration | Part of your team and processes | Separate business delivering a result |
| US tax form | W-2 | 1099-NEC |
| UK tax | PAYE through payroll | Self-employed or own limited company (IR35 may apply) |
- TRIGGERNew worker
- CONDITIONDo you control how and when they work?Yes → Likely employeeNo → Continue
- CONDITIONDo they work for other clients with own tools?Yes → Likely contractorNo → Get advice
- GOALCorrect classification and contract
1099 vs W-2: what changes for you
| W-2 EMPLOYEE | 1099 CONTRACTOR | |
|---|---|---|
| Who withholds income tax | You, every payday | Nobody; the contractor pays their own |
| Social Security and Medicare | You pay 7.65% and withhold 7.65% | Contractor pays 15.3% self-employment tax |
| Unemployment tax and workers’ comp | You pay | Not required |
| Overtime and minimum wage | Required for non-exempt staff | Not required |
| Benefits | Required at some sizes; usually offered | Not offered |
| Year-end form | W-2 by January 31 | 1099-NEC by January 31 if paid $2,000+ in 2026 (was $600) |
The tests used to decide
US: IRS common-law test (the old “20 factors”)
The IRS used to list 20 factors; it now groups them into three: behavioural control (do you control how the work is done?), financial control (who pays expenses, can the worker profit or lose, do they work for others?) and the relationship (contracts, benefits, permanence, and whether the work is a key part of your business). No single factor decides it. If you are unsure, you can ask the IRS for a ruling with Form SS-8.
US: the ABC test
Several states, including California, Massachusetts and New Jersey, use the stricter ABC test for some or all purposes. A worker is an employee unless all three are true: (A) they are free from your control, (B) the work is outside the usual course of your business, and (C) they are customarily engaged in an independent trade or business. Part B catches many businesses out: a web agency hiring “freelance” web developers usually fails it.
US: the Department of Labor’s economic reality test
For minimum wage and overtime under the FLSA, the Department of Labor asks whether the worker is economically dependent on you or genuinely in business for themselves, looking at control, investment, opportunity for profit or loss, permanence and how integral the work is.
UK: employment status and IR35
UK law recognises employees, workers and the self-employed, each with different rights. For tax, the off-payroll rules (IR35) apply when a contractor works through their own limited company but would be an employee if engaged directly. Medium and large clients must decide the contractor’s status and issue a status determination statement; for small clients the contractor’s own company decides. HMRC’s Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool gives a view you can rely on if your answers are accurate.
Classification checklist
| QUESTION | IF “YES”, LEANS TOWARDS EMPLOYEE |
|---|---|
| Do you set their hours and location? | ✓ |
| Do you provide equipment and training? | ✓ |
| Must they do the work personally (no substitutes)? | ✓ |
| Are they paid by time rather than per result? | ✓ |
| Do they work only for you, long term? | ✓ |
| Is the work a core part of what your business sells? | ✓ |
| Are they managed like your staff? | ✓ |
Consequences of getting it wrong
| WHERE | POSSIBLE COSTS |
|---|---|
| US | Back payroll taxes and penalties, back pay for overtime, benefits and interest; state fines (higher under ABC-test states) |
| UK | Unpaid income tax and National Insurance, holiday pay and other employment rights claims |
| Both | Legal fees, management time and reputational damage |
What a contractor agreement should include
- •Scope of work, deliverables and deadlines
- •Fees, invoicing and payment terms
- •That the contractor controls how the work is done and supplies their own equipment
- •Right to send a substitute (UK) and freedom to work for others
- •Intellectual property assignment and confidentiality
- •Insurance, liability and how either side can end the agreement
Common mistakes to avoid
How do I know if someone is an employee or a contractor?
Look at control (who decides how and when work is done), financial independence (own tools, other clients, chance of profit or loss) and integration into your business. If you control the work and they rely on you, they are probably an employee.
What is the difference between 1099 and W-2?
W-2 employees have income tax, Social Security and Medicare withheld through payroll, and the employer pays its share. 1099 contractors are paid gross, pay their own taxes and get a 1099-NEC if paid $2,000 or more in 2026.
What is the ABC test?
A stricter test used in states such as California, Massachusetts and New Jersey: a worker is an employee unless they are free from your control, do work outside your usual business, and run an independent business.
What is the IRS 20 factor test?
An older IRS checklist of 20 control factors. The IRS now groups them into behavioural control, financial control and the type of relationship; Form SS-8 lets you request a ruling.
What is IR35?
UK tax rules for contractors working through their own limited company who would be employees if hired directly. Medium and large clients decide status; small clients leave it to the contractor.















