0 / 24 done on this device
Stage 2 · Lesson 3 of 4 · GUIDE · 9 min

Interviewing and scorecards

Structured interviews

By the wpdailylive editorial team · Part of HR for small business, the complete guide

Key takeaways

  1. Structured interviews: Ask every candidate the same questions.
  2. Score against outcomes: Rate answers against the role’s outcomes, right after each interview.
  3. Work samples: A short practical task predicts performance well.
  4. A clear sequence: Phone screen, structured interview, work sample, final interview, references.
  5. Stay legal: Avoid questions about protected characteristics.
COMPETENCYQUESTIONSTRONG ANSWER SHOWS
OwnershipTell me about a project you led end to endClear decisions and results
Customer focusDescribe handling an unhappy clientEmpathy and a fix
LearningWhat did you learn from a recent mistake?Self-awareness
Role skillWork sample taskQuality and speed
  1. 01Phone screen20 minutes, basics and salary.
  2. 02Structured interview45 minutes, scorecard.
  3. 03Work sampleShort, paid if over 2 hours.
  4. 04Final interviewValues and questions.
  5. 05ReferencesTwo recent managers.
HOW WELL METHODS PREDICT JOB PERFORMANCE
Work sample0.54
Structured interview0.51
Unstructured interview0.38
Years of experience0.18
Schmidt & Hunter meta-analysis; validity coefficients approximate.

Key terms

ScorecardCriteria and ratings used to assess candidates.
Work sampleA small task similar to the job.

Scorecard example

COMPETENCYQUESTIONSCORE 1–5
Organisation“Tell me about a time you managed several deadlines at once.”
Customer communication“Describe a difficult customer call and how you handled it.”
Tools“Walk me through how you’d process a supplier invoice.”
Learning“What’s something you taught yourself recently?”

Questions to avoid

  • •Age, marital status, children or plans for children
  • •Religion, nationality or ethnicity
  • •Health or disability (beyond whether they can do essential tasks with adjustments)
  • •Pregnancy

How to interview candidates: a structured process

Structured interviews, where every candidate answers the same questions and is scored against the same criteria, predict job performance far better than unstructured chats. They’re also fairer and easier to defend if a decision is challenged.

  1. 01Pick 4–5 competenciesFrom the job description: for example organisation, customer communication, problem solving.
  2. 02Write one or two questions per competencyBehavioural (“tell me about a time…”) and situational (“what would you do if…”).
  3. 03Define what good looks likeWrite a 1, 3 and 5 answer for each question before interviewing.
  4. 04Score straight after each interviewIndependently, before talking to other interviewers.
  5. 05Debrief and decideCompare scores and evidence, not impressions.

Behavioural interview questions and the STAR method

Behavioural questions ask for real past examples, because past behaviour is the best predictor of future behaviour. Listen for a STAR answer: the Situation, the Task they faced, the Action they personally took and the Result. If an answer is vague, ask: “What did you do specifically?” and “What happened next?”

COMPETENCYSTRUCTURED INTERVIEW QUESTIONFOLLOW-UP
Problem solvingTell me about a problem at work you solved that others had missed.How did you know it had worked?
TeamworkDescribe a time you disagreed with a colleague. What did you do?What would you do differently?
ReliabilityTell me about a deadline you were at risk of missing.Who did you tell, and when?
LearningWhat’s something you taught yourself recently for work?How did you use it?
Customer focusDescribe a time you turned around an unhappy customer.What was the outcome?

Reference check questions

  • •How did you work with the candidate, and for how long?
  • •What were they best at?
  • •Where did they need the most support?
  • •How would you describe their reliability and communication?
  • •Would you hire them again? Why or why not?

Common mistakes to avoid

✕ Unstructured chatsUse a scorecard with defined answers.
✕ Deciding on gut feelCompare evidence and scores.
✕ Illegal questionsAvoid age, family, religion, health and nationality.
✕ Unpaid long take-home tasksKeep them short, or pay for them.
PEOPLE ALSO ASK
What is an interview scorecard?

A form listing the competencies for a role, the questions for each, and a 1–5 rating with descriptions of good and poor answers. Every interviewer fills it in independently.

What are structured interview questions?

The same set of job-related questions asked of every candidate in the same order, scored against agreed criteria.

What is the STAR method?

A way to answer behavioural questions: Situation, Task, Action, Result. Interviewers use it to check answers contain real, specific evidence.

What are good behavioural interview questions?

Questions that ask for real examples, such as “Tell me about a time you solved a problem others had missed” or “Describe a time you disagreed with a colleague.”

What questions should I ask a reference?

How they worked together, the candidate’s strengths and development areas, reliability and communication, and whether they would hire them again.