Performance reviews that help
Lightweight review template
By the wpdailylive editorial team · Part of HR for small business, the complete guide
Key takeaways
- Regular check-ins: Monthly one-to-ones plus two reviews a year.
- Simple questions: What went well, what to improve, and goals for next period.
- Rate outcomes: Judge results, not personality.
- Agree goals together: Shared goals get more commitment.
- No surprises: Feedback in reviews should never be new.
| SECTION | QUESTIONS |
|---|---|
| Wins | What are you proudest of? |
| Growth | What would help you do better? |
| Outcomes | How did you do against goals? |
| Next period | Three goals and support needed |
| Manager feedback | What should I do differently? |
- TRIGGERSelf-review submitted
- STEPManager review
- STEPReview conversation
- STEPGoals agreed in HR system
- GOALMonthly 1:1s track progress
Key terms
Lightweight review template
| QUESTION | EMPLOYEE ANSWERS | MANAGER ANSWERS |
|---|---|---|
| What went well this period? | ✓ | ✓ |
| What could have gone better? | ✓ | ✓ |
| Goals achieved vs agreed | ✓ | ✓ |
| What support do you need? | ✓ | |
| Goals for next period (3 max) | Agreed together | Agreed together |
One-to-one agenda (30 minutes)
- 1.Wins since last time (5 min)
- 2.Priorities and blockers (10 min)
- 3.Feedback both ways (10 min)
- 4.Development and next steps (5 min)
Performance review questions
| FOR THE MANAGER TO ASK | FOR THE EMPLOYEE TO ANSWER IN A SELF-EVALUATION |
|---|---|
| What did you achieve that you’re most proud of? | Which goals did I meet, miss or exceed, and why? |
| What got in your way? | What would help me do my best work? |
| Which skills do you want to build next? | Where do I want to be in a year? |
| What should we start, stop or continue as a team? | What feedback do I have for my manager? |
Self evaluation examples
- •“I cut our invoice turnaround from 10 days to 3 by setting up automatic reminders. Next I want to bring overdue invoices below 5%.”
- •“I missed the Q3 deadline for the client portal because I underestimated testing. I now plan a testing week into every project.”
- •“I’d like to lead a small project next quarter to build my management skills.”
Performance review examples (manager comments)
- •Strength: “Your client onboarding checklist reduced setup errors noticeably; three clients mentioned it.”
- •Development: “Updates sometimes arrive after deadlines. Let’s agree a weekly status note so issues surface earlier.”
- •Next steps: “Lead the supplier review in Q1, with a check-in every two weeks.”
1 on 1 meeting template
- 1.Wins since last time (5 minutes)
- 2.Priorities and blockers (10 minutes)
- 3.Feedback both ways (5 minutes)
- 4.Growth: one skill or goal (5 minutes)
- 5.Actions and owners (5 minutes)
OKRs for employees
OKRs (objectives and key results) pair an inspiring objective with 2–4 measurable results. For an individual: Objective “Make onboarding effortless for new clients”; key results “Setup time under 5 days”, “Onboarding satisfaction 9/10”, “Zero missed documents”. Keep them few and review them in one-to-ones, not just at review time.
Common mistakes to avoid
What should a performance review template include?
Achievements against goals, strengths with examples, development areas, the employee’s self-evaluation and comments, and goals for the next period.
What questions should I ask in a performance review?
What they achieved and are proud of, what got in the way, which skills they want to build and what the team should start, stop or continue.
What is a good self evaluation example?
“I cut invoice turnaround from 10 days to 3 by automating reminders. Next I want to bring overdue invoices below 5%.” Specific, measurable and forward-looking.
What should a 1 on 1 meeting cover?
Wins, priorities and blockers, two-way feedback, growth and agreed actions, in about 30 minutes.
What are OKRs for employees?
Objectives and key results: one clear objective with 2–4 measurable results, reviewed regularly in one-to-ones.















