Handling difficult conversations and discipline
A fair, documented process
By the wpdailylive editorial team · Part of HR for small business, the complete guide
Key takeaways
- Act early: Address issues before they grow.
- Private and specific: Use concrete examples, not general complaints.
- Clear expectations: Agree what needs to change and by when.
- Document everything: Record each conversation and outcome.
- Consistent process: Escalate to written warnings or a plan only if it continues.
- TRIGGERIssue identified
- STEPInformal conversation with examples
- CONDITIONImproved within agreed time?Yes → Close and recogniseNo → Written warning or PIP
- CONDITIONImproved during PIP?Yes → CloseNo → Final review and decision
- GOALFair, documented outcome
Key terms
Conversation structure
- 01State the issue factually“On 3, 10 and 17 March you arrived after 9:30.”
- 02Explain the impact“The café opened late and the team was short-staffed.”
- 03Listen“Help me understand what’s going on.”
- 04Agree expectations“From Monday, start at 9:00. Let me know by 8:00 if anything stops you.”
- 05Set a review date“We’ll check in two weeks.”
- 06Write it upSend a short summary the same day.
Formal process
| STEP | WHAT HAPPENS |
|---|---|
| Informal conversation | Documented note |
| Investigation | Gather facts before any hearing |
| Hearing | Employee can respond (UK: right to be accompanied) |
| Outcome | Warning, improvement plan or dismissal, in writing |
| Appeal | Chance to appeal to someone not involved |
How to discipline an employee fairly
- 01Address it early and informallyA private conversation often fixes the issue.
- 02InvestigateGet the facts before deciding anything.
- 03Hold a formal meetingExplain the concern, show evidence, listen to their side.
- 04Decide and confirm in writingVerbal or written warning, with what must change and by when.
- 05Support and reviewTraining, check-ins, a review date.
- 06Escalate if neededFinal written warning, then dismissal if nothing improves.
Performance improvement plan (PIP) template
| SECTION | EXAMPLE |
|---|---|
| The gap | Client reports were late in 6 of the last 8 weeks |
| What good looks like | Reports sent by 5pm every Friday |
| Support provided | Weekly check-in, report template, training on the tool |
| Timeline | 6 weeks, with reviews at weeks 2 and 4 |
| Outcome | If targets aren’t met, further action up to dismissal may follow |
Written warning template
“Dear Alex, following our meeting on 4 March, this letter confirms a first written warning for repeated lateness: you arrived after 9:15 on 7 occasions in February. We expect you to start by 9:00 every day. We agreed a later start on Wednesdays for your childcare. This warning will stay on file for 6 months. If there’s no improvement, further action may be taken. You may appeal within 5 working days by writing to Priya Shah.”
How to fire an employee
- •Make sure you have followed your process, documented warnings and given a fair chance to improve (unless it’s gross misconduct)
- •US: check at-will status, discrimination and retaliation risk, and final pay timing in your state
- •UK: follow the ACAS Code; employees with 2 years’ service can claim unfair dismissal (changing under the Employment Rights Act)
- •Hold a short, private meeting with a witness; be clear and kind
- •Confirm in writing with final pay, benefits and equipment return
- •Remove system access at the end of the meeting
Common mistakes to avoid
How do I discipline an employee?
Talk informally first, investigate, hold a formal meeting, give a written warning with clear expectations and a review date, support improvement, and escalate only if needed.
What is a performance improvement plan?
A written plan setting out the performance gap, what good looks like, support provided, a timeline (often 30–90 days) and possible outcomes.
What should a written warning include?
The issue with specific examples, the expected improvement, support offered, how long the warning stays on file, consequences of no improvement and the right to appeal.
How do I fire an employee legally?
Follow your process and document it, check discrimination and retaliation risks, hold a private meeting, confirm in writing, pay final wages on time and remove access.
How do I have a difficult conversation at work?
Prepare facts, meet privately, describe the specific behaviour and its impact, listen, agree next steps and follow up in writing.















